Cognitive impairment and the dementias, of which Alzheimer’s disease is the most common, are some of the largest health challenges to our society. There are 50 million people with dementia worldwide, and this has been projected to increase to 180 million by 2050. There are about 180,000 new cases of dementia each year in the UK alone.
Following the usual interventionist model, we look to advances in molecular pathology and pharmacology to provide treatments for dementia. Sadly, the best current drug treatment only delays the symptoms by a modest time period, perhaps months (Ballard et al, 2011).
Could a different answer be right under our nose? What if we could reduce the burden of dementia markedly just by changing our lifestyle?
A recent systematic review and meta-analysis sheds some interesting light on these questions (Beydoun et al, 2014).
Methods
The authors wanted to determine what proportion of cognitive health outcomes, including Alzheimer’s disease, could be attributed to modifiable risk factors.
To do this they conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of cross-sectional and cohort studies in MEDLINE.
The following factors were focused on, with exposure defined in brackets:
- Socio-economic status as indicated by educational level (less than 8 years);
- Smoking status (ever smoked);
- Homocysteine levels (low);
- Omega-3 Fatty Acids (low);
- Physical activity (<2-3 times per week).
They calculated the risk ratio of incident Alzheimer’s disease based on presence of the risk factor.
They also calculated the population-attributable risk (PAR), a measure of how much a disease would be reduced in incidence if a risk factor was eliminated entirely.
Results
31 studies (with samples sizes>300) were entered into the meta-analysis.
Meta-analysis found that:
- Lower educational status increased your risk of AD by almost double (RR=1.99, 95% CI: 1.30 to 3.04)
- A high homocysteine level increased your risk almost by double as well (RR=1.93, 95% CI: 1.50 to 2.49)
- Having ever smoked increased your risk of AD by 37% (95% CI: 23-52%)
- Higher physical activity decreased your risk by 42% (95% CI: 30-51%)
- Increased intake of omega-3 fatty acids decreased your risk by 33% (95% CI: 4-53%)
- For physical activity the PAR was 31.9% (95% CI: 22.7-41.2%)
- This means that if everyone in the UK was to move out of the category of ‘physically inactive’ there would be almost a third less cases of Alzheimer’s, equating to 60,000 less new cases a year in the UK
- For smoking the PAR was 31.09% (95% CI: 17.9-44.3%), meaning if everyone in the UK was a non-smoker there would also be about a decrease of a third in the incidence of Alzheimer’s.
Publication bias was not found to be present in the studies used for the meta-analysis.
There was found to be significant heterogeneity in the studies of education and smoking, but other studies were found to be largely homogeneous.
Limitations
However, there are several pinches of salt to take with this heady meal.
- Only one medical database was used (MEDLINE), so it’s highly likely that studies exist that could have been included in the review
- Significant heterogeneity was detected in the studies, which explored the effect of smoking and education
- There was no quality assessment of the individual studies
- The attribution of causation is limited as all studies were observational
It is worth noting, however, how consistent this paper’s findings are with another study recently published in Lancet Neurology (Norton et al, 2014), which found the population-attributable risk for Alzheimer’s to be:
- 19% for low educational attainment;
- 22% for physical activity;
- and attributed 30-50% of all Alzheimer’s cases to seven modifiable risk factors.
Conclusions
Despite the limitations of this study, and the lack of clear evidence of causation, the findings of a number of studies demonstrating the link between cognitive outcomes, including Alzheimer’s disease, and modifiable risk factors are startling.
The size of the effects detected are particularly interesting in comparison to the, at best, modest effects of the best drugs available.
Is it heretical in our age of technological enthusiasm to suggest that the best way to reduce the incidence of these devastating diseases involves change at the level of our societies (in healthcare, research funding and lifestyles) rather than at the level of protein folding? Could we change the way we eat, the way we travel, target socioeconomic disadvantage, and the complex social issues underlying tobacco and obesity use to tackle this problem?
Is that really so much more difficult than spending billions of dollars trying to understand the most complex system yet encountered (the human brain) and then attempt to find a molecular switch that will reverse the accumulated damage of years of neurotoxic living?
Research waste
Could the research that we conduct also connect up to the social implications for our society more closely? The issue of wasted research funding has been addressed recently by a series in the Lancet. These papers suggested that up to 85% of the 240 billion dollars spent each year on biomedical research was wasted.
In particular, waste is caused by:
- Funding medical research that does not match the actual needs of the public
- Ignoring what is already known
Links
Beydoun MA, Beydoun HA, Gamaldo AA, Teel A, Zonderman AB, Wang Y. (2014) Epidemiologic studies of modifiable factors associated with cognition and dementia: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Public Health. 2014 Jun 24;14:643. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-14-643.
Ballard C, Gauthier S, Corbett A, Brayne C, Aarsland D, Jones E. (2011) Alzheimer’s disease. The Lancet, Volume 377, Issue 9770, 19–25 March 2011, Pages 1019-1031, ISSN 0140-6736, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(10)61349-9. [Abstract]
Norton S, Matthews FE, Barnes DE, Yaffe K, Brayne C. (2014) Potential for primary prevention of Alzheimer’s disease: an analysis of population-based data, The Lancet Neurology, Volume 13, Issue 8, August 2014, Pages 788-794, ISSN 1474-4422, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S1474-4422(14)70136-X. [Abstract]
Research Waste: increasing value, reducing waste. Open access website with all of the Lancet series of articles on research waste.
GoldenMindful
11 years agoMedLinkNeurol
11 years agodlhampton
11 years agoNHFTNHSLibrary
11 years agokaleidocyte
11 years agoSteveLaitner
11 years agoHolly Miller
11 years agofelly500
11 years agofelly500
11 years agojpraft
11 years agopash22
11 years agoSarahMMcKay
11 years agoaghoury79
11 years agowillyumlu
11 years agoLunaCentifanti
11 years agolajkirby
11 years agoDhanarajtweet
11 years agopgmm03
11 years agoninjabitch
11 years agoNeuroskill
11 years agojkrinn
11 years agoitsmepanda1
11 years agojohnnyrockdogs
11 years agoGill_Livingston
11 years agomiranda_jane123
11 years agomcostaenf
11 years agoAmanda Collins-Eade
11 years agounahume
11 years agoElisabetTubau
11 years agonyraksniktaw
11 years agorunmeditate
11 years agoAddictionNotDis
11 years agosaraadams2009
11 years agoMental_Elf
11 years agoLifestyleElf
11 years agogerry_molloy
11 years agoBerniceTigheRD
11 years agoTreasa_corbett
11 years agomgute_pmgute
11 years agoJeremyWexlerMSW
11 years agoMental_Elf
11 years agoaghoury79
11 years agolisatrigg
11 years agoHHLibService
11 years agoBwoodHighland
11 years agoSysnetCardiff
11 years agoSysnetCardiff
11 years agoSysnetCardiff
11 years agoClaireLucas2
11 years agoMental_Elf
11 years agomiinverness
11 years agoJason Desoisa
11 years agoBwoodHighland
11 years agojasminwer
11 years agodnunan79
11 years agoSCEW86
11 years agoClinHealthSci
11 years agoMental_Elf
11 years agoKatie_nz
11 years agoMLChatterton
11 years agokatejjeffery
11 years agoMrBlanding
11 years agoTashaFoundation
11 years agoFrankCurtisLib
11 years agoPerrymanBowen
11 years agoTheJaneJames
11 years agoCECLibrary
11 years agoDrDannyPenman
11 years agoAgencyNurse
11 years agoMental_Elf
11 years agoSalbal11
11 years agoJune Dunnett
11 years agoThe Mental Elf
11 years agorichki55
11 years agoHealthUKTD
11 years agoanniecoops
11 years agoStoneygateLucy
11 years agoKayFSheldon
11 years agoMental_Elf
11 years agoClinHealthSci
11 years agoAddictionNotDis
11 years agowolfdove1016
11 years agoMental_Elf
11 years ago'Sue Mario
11 years agoAdelina Comas-Herrera
11 years agoMODEMproject
11 years agoSocialCareElf
11 years agococklewoman
11 years agoaghoury79
11 years agoiVivekMisra
11 years agoSwimmingCat100
11 years agoalismithjohns
11 years ago