We need long-term strategies to reduce the risk of relapse or recurrence of depression. This is because 16% of the population are affected by major depressive disorder and at least 45% of them experience recurrences of the illness. People who experience these recurrences can typically have 7-8 depressive episodes over their entire life.
Various treatments for depression are available these days, but most of them are applied only when people are in the acute disease stage. The National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence guidance (NICE, 2009) strongly recommends the continuing use of antidepressant medication in medication-responders. The period for using medication varies from at least 6 months to more than 2 years if the person presents a serious risk of recurrence. These recommendations are debated by the scientific community because there is a lack of evidence in this area.
NICE also recommends individual cognitive behavioural therapy and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy as preventive measures after remission from depression.
A recent meta-analysis published in the Journal of Affective Disorders (Biesheuvel-Leliefeld et al, 2015) investigates the effects of preventive psychological interventions, antidepressant medication (ADM) and treatment as usual (TAU) on reducing the risk of relapse or recurrence. The scope of this study was to include more types of psychological interventions than studies have previously, and they also included different forms for delivering therapy, including Internet-based therapy and booster sessions.
They hypothesised that different types of psychological interventions are equally effective, and not inferior to ADM or TAU.
Methods
25 studies out of 3,537 met all the inclusion criteria and were reviewed by the authors. The paper researching phase and selection criteria were provided by the authors and a thorough explication is provided for the statistical analysis conducted.
The inclusion criteria were: a randomised clinical trial, examining adult patients, with recurrent major depressive disorder, who were in remission at randomisation, were receiving a preventive psychological intervention aiming at reducing the risk of relapse or recurrence and had a comparison to a control condition.
Results
The results are based on the analysis conducted on 25 studies with a total number of 2,055 patients that met the criteria.
- Although the authors did not find prevention trials based on therapies other than cognitive-behavioural therapy, mindfulness-based therapy and interpersonal therapy, as it was proposed in the beginning of the article, the results show that psychological interventions are superior to TAU when aiming to preventing relapse or recurrence over two years (RR=0.64, p < 0.001).
- They also found that psychological interventions are not inferior to ADM, showing that they are more effective than ADM in reducing the risk of relapse or a recurrence (RR=0.83, p < 0.017).
- Regarding their third hypothesis, different types of psychological interventions are equally effective, the authors found an effect size roughly similar. Sixteen trials included cognitive therapy, three trials included interpersonal therapy and six trials included mindfulness-based cognitive therapy.
Conclusions
In their discussion of the results the authors conclude that their review is the first one targeting the effect of all types of preventive psychological interventions on relapse or recurrence after remissions. They state that they included ADM and TAU as separate control groups, “which is new and very much awaited in the field”.
Besides showing that psychological interventions are superior to TAU and not inferior to ADM, they also revealed that the effectiveness of interventions aimed at preventive relapse or recurrence after remissions were enhanced when the patient had received an intervention whilst in the acute phase of the depression. Interventions received before included: psychological intervention, antidepressant medication or both combined.
Limitations
This study has limitations, some of which are acknowledged by the authors of the study.
- In the beginning the authors stated that they wanted to include other types of psychological intervention which were not included in previous research. In the end they managed to include just interpersonal therapy, because the other two interventions (cognitive-behavioural therapy and mindfulness based cognitive therapy) were included before. Maybe we should wonder why?
- Then, as stated by the authors, the studies were different in their methodological design and had poor description of important factors as TAU.
- Publication bias is another limitation, and the roughly similar effect size of different types of psychological interventions was based just on the pooled results of the studies.
- Other limitations, not of this meta-analysis, but of the included trials, are represented by their low overall quality according to the GRADE evidence profile and the number of previous depressive episodes, which might have been under-reported. These limitations are also acknowledged by the authors.
Summary
Our understanding of the mechanisms that influence major depressive disorder and the risk of relapse or recurrence after remission has increased over the years, but we still need a lot of research in this area.
This review identifies some important aspects regarding psychological interventions and their applicability in preventing relapse or recurrence in depression, by analysing 25 published studies.
However, they did not succeed in comparing all types of therapy applied in depression, as they were proposing, due to a lack of studies which might investigate the effectiveness of interventions. This lack of evidence is not without reason and maybe unpublished data could help shed further light on this matter.
Links
Primary paper
Biesheuvel-Leliefeld KEM, Kok GD, Bockting CLH, Cuijpers P, Hollon SD, van Marwijk HWJ, Smit F. (2015) Effectiveness of psychological interventions in preventing recurrence of depressive disorder: Meta-analysis and meta-regression. Journal of Affective Disorders, 174C, 400-410. 10.1016/j.jad.2014.12.016
Other references
Depression: the treatment and management of depression in adults (update). NICE CG90, 2009.
Preventive cognitive therapy when continuing or stopping antidepressants
7 years agoCan psychotherapy reduce the risk of relapse or recurrence of depression? - National Elf Service
11 years agoQualitasRes
11 years agoNHKPVicky
11 years agogeorgevaraiza
11 years agoPost Of The Week – Saturday 20th June 2015 | DHSB/DHSG Psychology Research Digest
11 years agoraluca_lucacel
11 years agoBigMadTweeter
11 years agoascbtni
11 years agoProfSarahCowley
11 years agoKarl_Tooher
11 years agoNickyjparis
11 years agoJoanneYounge
11 years agoNRHPUK
11 years agoSameiHuda
11 years agoMental_Elf
11 years agoGlobalMindBody
11 years agohartley_pam
11 years agoHealthwatchTame
11 years agonurte281
11 years agoLovingSanders
11 years agoActivaMent
11 years agoCharliHuggett
11 years agojuli3marshall
11 years agopersonfirst
11 years agoPBTDoyle
11 years agoLynn Staffylover
11 years agoHWOldham
11 years agoresilienceflow
11 years agotapchat
11 years ago_artforchange
11 years agoAllyThornton27
11 years agoplaylablondon
11 years agoTAJDP
11 years agoJayarava
11 years agoraluca_lucacel
11 years agoJayarava
11 years agonigeldawsoncpc
11 years agomuzafferkaser
11 years agoNeedMoreCourage
11 years agoMental_Elf
11 years agohubgodalming
11 years agowolf_chri
11 years agoraluca_lucacel
11 years agoDrLouis_D
11 years agoVoiceOfJuDah
11 years agoTerryMooreMSW
11 years agoLynnzie Stirling
11 years agoThomas Munro
11 years agoFiona Walker
11 years agoChristina Williams
11 years agoSusanne Munro
11 years agoChristina Armstrong-Graham
11 years agoArPAPsych
11 years agoaghoury79
11 years agoarchonions
11 years agoUdderwisePsych
11 years agoTrudijackson2
11 years agoTrudijackson2
11 years agoSameiHuda
11 years agoCrhysbartlett
11 years agoraluca_lucacel
11 years agodrabagnall
11 years agodrabagnall
11 years agobecxmann
11 years agoMental_Elf
11 years agotombssimon
11 years agoDrShirleyLock
11 years agoBuffDavis
11 years agoTamsin_J_Ford
11 years agoemipats
11 years ago_terriporter
11 years agoThe Mental Elf
11 years agoSarah Harte
11 years agoMargaret A. Stout
11 years agoAlan Murphy
11 years agoleftoutside2
11 years agoTravisHillLPC
11 years agotobyornot_
11 years agoBaxendenPhysio
11 years agostrecker_roger
11 years agoSandra Thibault
11 years agoEd Freshwater
11 years agoHHLibService
11 years agoVictoria Edwards
11 years agoTokyoTherapy
11 years agoE_L_Wilkinson
11 years agoTrainInnovate
11 years agoPreciousThing
11 years agopsalkovskis
11 years agoAntonia Borneo
11 years agoRachel Essex
11 years agoKatie Simpson
11 years agoSarah Champion
11 years agoArt Therapy Study
11 years agopsychiatrist81
11 years agoCounsellorSally
11 years agoNHFTNHSLibrary
11 years agoHuttenRebecca
11 years agoIonasca Bogdan
11 years agoDiane Edwards
11 years agopaulramchandani
11 years agoMartingaughan
11 years agoPatrickJSweeney
11 years agoSmithson71
11 years agoraluca_lucacel
11 years agopaoma294
11 years agoMental_Elf
11 years agoCatalyseC
11 years agoTheCornerCRI
11 years agoSCIE_sco
11 years agotheholytoad
11 years agoElaine McLaren
11 years agojosephine_n
11 years agoMunichKJPClinic
11 years agoAffecttherapy
11 years agorachellanecouns
11 years agoKarenHohler
11 years agoBoT11_17
11 years agoRaluca Lucacel
11 years agoKeith Laws
11 years agoAndrew Philip Holden
11 years agoiVivekMisra
11 years agoClaireWalshLCP
11 years agocprjournal
11 years agomatthewrbennion
11 years agoNickyjparis
11 years agoraluca_lucacel
11 years agoEvermel
11 years agoApplebyAppleby
11 years agoststherapies
11 years agoaghoury79
11 years ago121Therapy
11 years ago