Menu
  • CPD online - National Elf Service
  • Take your event #BeyondTheRoom
  • Training
  • #ElfHelp
  • Contact us
  • News

No bias. No misinformation. No spin. Just what you need!

The Social Care Elf

  • Home
  • About
  • Categories
      • Cost effectiveness
      • Evaluation and impact assessment
      • Financial management
      • Financial sustainability
      • Integration
      • Needs assessment
      • Outcomes based commissioning
      • Partnership working
      • Population health
      • Resource allocation
      • Service reconfiguration
      • Service review and improvement
      • Specialised commissioning
      • Strategy development and planning
      • Technology
      • Urgent care
      • Variation
      • caries
      • cleft lip and palate
      • dental workforce
      • endodontics
      • oral and maxillofacial surgery
      • oral cancer
      • oral health
      • oral medicine and pathology
      • orthodontics
      • periodontal disease
      • restorative dentistry
      • temporomandibular joint disorders
      • tooth surface loss
    • Diagnosis
      • brain imaging
      • diagnostic test
      • risk factors
      • screening programme
      • screening test
      • behaviour
      • ICT
      • learning styles
      • numeracy
      • phonics
      • reading
      • science
      • social emotional
      • social skills
      • wellbeing
      • autistic spectrum disorder
      • challenging behaviour
      • communication
      • down syndrome
      • parents with learning disabilities
      • prader-willi syndrome
      • profound and multiple learning disability
      • ADHD
      • anxiety
      • bipolar disorder
      • dementia
      • depression
      • eating disorders
      • OCD
      • panic disorder
      • personality disorders
      • psychosis
      • PTSD
      • schizophrenia
      • self-harm
      • sleep disorders
      • substance misuse
      • suicide
      • autoimmune and inflammatory diseases
      • fibromyalgia
      • fractures and dislocations
      • musculoskeletal pain
      • neck and back pain
      • osteoarthritis
      • osteoporosis
      • rheumatoid arthritis
      • soft tissue injuries
      • spinal conditions
      • spondyloarthropathies
    • Other health conditions
      • blood-borne viruses
      • cancer
      • cardiovascular disease
      • chronic fatigue syndrome
      • comorbidity
      • epilepsy
      • multiple sclerosis
      • sleep apnoea
      • traumatic brain injury
    • Populations and settings
      • advocacy
      • black and minority ethnic
      • caregivers
      • child and adolescent
      • commissioning
      • community settings
      • crime
      • deinstitutionalisation
      • employment
      • end of life
      • family carers
      • hospital admissions
      • housing
      • later life
      • LGBTQ+
      • liaison psychiatry
      • loneliness
      • older adult
      • parenting
      • patient safety
      • perinatal mental health
      • poverty
      • pregnancy
      • primary care
      • quality of life
      • refugee
      • schools
      • secondary care
      • service user involvement
      • shared care
      • sport
      • training
      • vulnerable people
      • young adult
    • Publication types
      • appraisal
      • audit
      • case study
      • case-control
      • cohort study
      • consultation
      • cross-sectional
      • economic analysis
      • economic evaluation
      • guideline
      • legislation
      • literature review
      • meta-analysis
      • mixed methods
      • observational study
      • patient information
      • policy
      • prospective study
      • qualitative
      • questionnaire
      • randomised controlled trial
      • report
      • scoping review
      • statistics
      • survey
      • systematic review
      • technology assessment
      • training resource
      • umbrella review
      • website
    • Social care
      • coproduction
      • equality and diversity
      • evidence based social care
      • home care
      • integration
      • local authorities
      • nursing homes
      • personal budgets and direct payments
      • personalisation
      • reablement
      • residential care
      • safeguarding
      • social care decision making
      • social care training
      • social care workforce
      • social work
      • support planning
      • user led organisations
      • voluntary and community sector
    • Treatment
      • antidepressants
      • antipsychotics
      • CBT
      • cognitive bias modification (cbm)
      • complementary and alternative
      • digital health
      • exercise
      • medicines
      • mental illness prevention
      • mindfulness
      • other
      • psychotherapy
      • rehabilitation
      • self-management
      • surgical
      • systems
      • telehealth
      • topical
  • Podcasts
Search

Home » Posts » Social care » social care training » Teaching international social work: a comparative study

Teaching international social work: a comparative study

31 Responses »
Aug 20 2015
Profile photo of Tanya Moore
Posted by
Tanya Moore
map

Social work is an international profession. It has an international definition, a global agenda and values based on principles of social justice and a commitment to the world wide promotion of equality and dignity.

For social workers practising in the UK where much of our work has a local authority focus, awareness of international social work (ISW) can offer a wider perspective and a reminder for busy practitioners that social work is more than the tasks completed for their agency.

Lalayants, Doel and Kachkachishvili’s research is on different teaching and learning approaches employed for ISW, gives an overview of the literature that highlights the relevance of ISW then identifies and evaluates some of the teaching approaches used from the differing perspectives of students from three different countries.

The global impact of poverty and oppression, the prevalence of issues such as human trafficking, homelessness, HIV/AIDS and the need for social work support for people seeking refuge or asylum are well documented. These are all obvious issues for ISW but will be of equal interest and relevance to social workers practicing within their home countries. Learning about approaches used elsewhere can develop appreciation of difference and cultural sensitivity. It can challenge values and beliefs biased to a practitioner’s home country. It can introduce new and innovative ways of thinking and promote collaborative relationships for practice, education and research.

Universities are responding to this by developing ISW perspectives in existing curricula and offering specialised ISW courses. Literature about the teaching methods used is limited but examples are offered.

One example is the ‘reverse mission’ student exchange programme. This is a much adapted version of the Christian missionary model but instead of conversion to Christianity, the goal is to ‘search for subjugated knowledge’ by listening to the experiences and views of marginalised people. Reverse mission’s aim is learn from local people about how problems are solved thus avoiding ‘professional imperialism’; the imposing of own approaches and methods onto local populations.

Students value international placements but unfortunately there are few opportunities. This gap could be filled by attendance at conferences and workshops as well as development of electronic communication with international colleagues. The example of a week-long colloquium on ISW practice and research is offered.

What the literature review doesn’t offer is an understanding of student’s preferences for ISW teaching approaches (pedagogy) and the study attempts to address this.

This study compared student preferences for international social work teaching approaches in US, UK and Georgia

This study compared student preferences for international social work teaching approaches in US, UK and Georgia.

Methods

The study took a comparison of the pedagogical approach to ISW courses in The City University of New York, USA, Sheffield Hallam University, UK and Tbilisi State University, Georgia. This formed part of a larger project exploring student’s views of international social work.

530 student email addresses were initially contacted. 285 students responded and were surveyed. 194 from USA, 52 from UK and 39 from Georgia. The same survey questionnaire containing quantitative and qualitative elements was used across the three universities.

Students were asked to complete the sentence

  • ‘For me, what will make a class on ISW successful is…’

Responses were grouped under the broad headings that are set out below along with an indication of the themes presented in the answers. The percentage in brackets indicates the percentage of students whose answers fell into that category.

Students were asked to complete a sentence about what makes a successful class on international social work.

Students were asked to complete a sentence about what makes a successful class on international social work.

Findings

The different themes, specific responses and response rates were are as follows:

Information and knowledge

American students (32%)

  • …comparisons of social work practices and international policies across different countries
  • …how to develop reciprocal relationships that are mindful of America’s history of dominance
  • …impact of global events and how these affect practice
  • …job opportunities in global social work

UK students (14%)

  • …awareness of current issues in global social work
  • …interesting and understandable content
  • …lessons well organised

Georgian students (42%)

  • …current international issues

Direct contact

American students (11%)

  • …collaborations, first-hand accounts and guest speakers from social work from other countries ‘going abroad’
  • …Skype connecting with another class

UK students (19%)

  • …views from different countries; lecturers/social workers/students/service users

Georgian students (4%)

  • …exposure to ISW professionals

Professor qualities

American students (9%)

  • …well organised course, well informed, engaging teachers

Discussion and debate in small groups

UK students (33%)

  • …open and honest discussion and debate in small groups

Georgian students (11%)

  • …student discussions re global social problems, their consequences and the role and involvement of social workers

Practical examples

American students (9%)

  • …experiential and practice based examples of ISW and how to get involved
  • …films/interviews with people involved
  • …concrete examples of the challenges involved

UK students (21%)

  • …video clips/role play

Skills to translate theory to practice

Georgian students (31%)

  • …skills to translate theory into practice; practice based approaches, real life application of theoretical concepts

Printed materials in native language

Georgian students (9%)

  • …reading materials in Georgian

Visual examples

Georgian students (3%)

  • …statistical tables, film clips

Conclusion

The authors conclude that

While there were different preferences for content- and process-driven approaches in teaching, students’ common interest was in gaining practice examples and exposure to real-life practice of international social work in their own and other countries. The findings suggest that international social work education needs to be more experiential and practice-based.
International social work education needs to be more experiential and practice-based.

International social work education needs to be more experiential and practice-based.

Strengths and limitations

As just three universities are included in this study, findings can lead to suggestions rather than conclusions. The significantly higher number of American respondents mean that more individual American views were represented which makes it harder to understand what might be a US perspective and what might just be a louder voice because of more respondents.

If national pedagogic trends are represented though these three universities, student’s expectations may already be shaped by their experience of these and respondents may not have been able to make the leap of imagination required of the open ‘what would make it better’ question.

Summing up

The study identified differences in pedagogical expectations; Georgian and American students highlighted the importance of a content driven delivery with little reference to opportunities for discussion. UK students highlighted emphasis on small group work with little reference to content. Georgian responses tended to be more focussed on professional rather than personal concerns.

The authors suggest significance here for cross-national teaching; a UK lecturer shouldn’t assume that because UK students expect and prefer small group discussions, the same could be said of students in Georgia.

Pedagogical similarities were found in the common requirement for clear practice examples and understanding of what social workers in other countries do.

The study also identified a call for students to have contact with social work students in other countries and the authors suggest that international student alliances could be embedded into ISW courses using Facebook and other social networking tools.

There was some interest from US and UK students in the creation of an international community of social work students.

The authors identify the need for future research to explore the outcomes of different pedagogical approaches and international exchanges as well as the need for a systematic comparison of the effectiveness of the different models of ISW.

The interest from students in the work of international colleagues could be an important message for social work teaching in the UK. Although many of our students will become local authority social workers when they graduate, the study may indicate a wider understanding of the social work role.

Encouraging social work students to connect as suggested here with colleagues in other countries may help to maintain focus on the broader value and skillset of social work even when faced with the processes of many domestic social work tasks.

Social work students should connect with peers in other countries to keep a broader focus on skills and values.

Social work students should connect with peers in other countries to keep a broader focus on skills and values.

Link

Lalayants, M., Doel, M. & Kachkachishvili, I. (2014)  Pedagogy of international social work: a comparative study in the USA, UK, and Georgia. European Journal of Social Work 17 (4) pp. 455-474 [Abstract]

Share on Facebook Tweet this on Twitter Share on LinkedIn Share on Google+
Mark as read

Share this post:

Share on Facebook Tweet this on Twitter Share on LinkedIn Share on Google+ Share via email
Create a personal elf note about this blog
Tagged with: comparative study, international social work, learning, pedagogy, qualitative research, social work education, social work students, social workers, students, university
Profile photo of Tanya Moore

Tanya Moore

Tanya is a registered social worker and fellow of the Higher Education Academy. She is a senior clinical lecturer in social work and social care at the Tavistock and Portman NHS trust and Head of Social Work at Hertfordshire Adult Care Services Tanya is equally enthusiastic about social work, social care and teaching.

More posts

Follow me here –

  • Twitter
Logging In...

Profile cancel

Sign in with Twitter Sign in with Facebook
or

Not published

  • 31 Replies
  • 1 Comment
  • 28 Tweets
  • 2 Facebook
  • 0 Pingbacks
Last reply was August 20, 2015
0907rae retweeted thispeterjsimcock retweeted thisIntipton retweeted this
Linda Holt liked thisThe Social Care Elf liked this
  1. @DaveMarsland1
    View August 20, 2015

    “@SocialCareElf: Teaching international social work: http://t.co/ilhKoPZT3R” Great, but if not on Key Skills Lists is it likely in future?

    Reply
    • @tanyamoorehertsreplied:
      View August 20, 2015

      @DaveMarsland1 @SocialCareElf Agree. Needs 2b in drivers 4 course design. Reminder that SWs shld set SW education agenda not just employers.

      Reply
  2. @SocialCareElf
    View August 20, 2015

    Welcome to the Woodland @tanyamooreherts ! Smashing debut blog here: http://t.co/rlmV4EOu5s #socialwork #education

    tanyamooreherts retweeted thisdawnherts retweeted thisPositiveSimply retweeted this
    Reply
    • @tanyamoorehertsreplied:
      View August 20, 2015

      @SocialCareElf Thank you. It’s great to be here and delighted to have produced my first SocialCareElf blog

      Reply
  3. @SocialCareElf
    View August 20, 2015

    Today @tanyamooreherts makes her debut with a blog on a comparative study on international #socialwork #education http://t.co/Qq7UgULhqO

    tanyamooreherts retweeted thisGeraldineF_HSCB retweeted thisCforWR retweeted thissimonjduffy retweeted this
    Reply
  4. @tanyamooreherts
    View August 20, 2015

    My 1st blog for @SocialCareElf. Talking about teaching international SW. https://t.co/XTdxzwXgFn

    SocialCareElf retweeted thisbill_mumford retweeted thisIsoMullarkey retweeted thisPerDarling retweeted this
    Reply
  5. @SocialCareElf
    View August 20, 2015

    Teaching and learning in international #socialwork – how do US, UK and Georgia compare? @tanyamooreherts finds out! http://t.co/Vl4CWH7toC

    hevy50 retweeted this
    Reply
  6. @SocialCareElf
    View August 20, 2015

    #Socialwork students learning from international practice in UK, US and Georgia: what works for whom and where? http://t.co/yIM9bg5Jni

    CareKnowledgeEd retweeted this
    Reply
  7. @SocialCareElf
    View August 20, 2015

    Don’t miss: Teaching international social work: a comparative study http://t.co/OqXPbqYkhZ #EBP

    Reply
  8. @scwru
    View August 21, 2015

    Teaching international social work discussed by @tanyamooreherts for @SocialCareElf: http://t.co/RsVV529WNG

    SocialCareElf retweeted thistgreenltd retweeted this
    Reply
  9. Profile photo of Jean RobinsonJean Robinson
    View September 9, 2015

    Whilst I welcome an international study on social work, I so wish someone would explore, and be honest about, translation of social work skills from one country to another. Many SWs in the UK are imported, and my observations of their approach and reports after accompanying clients has raised many questions. Social class and regional differences in the UK are substantial, and the nuances take a lifetime to learn. Even SWs from Europe have shown a level of misunderstanding which was almost comical. As a former lay member of the GMC and a nursing and midwifery national committee, I soon realised that even medicine, nursing and midwifery – which have a much higher technical learning content – were not easily transferrable to other countries. If we stopped pretending, and started honestly discussing practical problems, everyone would b enefit.
    Jean Robinson, President, Association for Improvements in the Maternity Services

    Reply
Try out our members features!

Sign up now. It’s free! Or Sign in

We can help you:

  • 1Keep up to date with the latest research
  • 2Connect with experts and colleagues
  • 3Contribute to your professional development
Tell me more about the benefits of membership

FOLLOW the Social Care Elf

  • Find us on Facebook
  • Follow us on Twitter
  • Follow us on Google+
  • Read our RSS feed
  • Find us on LinkedIn

Twitter

  • That's a wrap on our Elfmas 🎁! We hope you enjoyed reading all our blogs this year. Tis the season for Elves! And… https://t.co/OnSAbjI7qF December 23, 2021 Reply Retweet Favorite
  • "When is the best time for a person with dementia to move to a care home?": In this blog, @js_nieman examined the f… https://t.co/TQvB4WZGWW December 23, 2021 Reply Retweet Favorite
  • "COVID-19: Casting forward the shadow": In this blog, @JillManthorpe reported on an international comparison of Eng… https://t.co/nnCqSJXVSq December 23, 2021 Reply Retweet Favorite
  • "Self-Funders in England: How much choice and control do they really have?": In this blog, @NatalieLeworthy discuss… https://t.co/qTmHKmjXPt December 22, 2021 Reply Retweet Favorite
  • "Enhancing primary care support for informal carers": In this blog, @charnnunes explored the views of professional… https://t.co/ywc6Z4Kn2b December 22, 2021 Reply Retweet Favorite
SocialCareElf

Recent Posts

  • When is the best time for a person with dementia to move to a care home?
  • COVID-19: Casting forward the shadow
  • Self-Funders in England: How much choice and control do they really have?
  • Enhancing primary care support for informal carers
  • Implementing guidelines to protect long-term care facilities

Suggest a paper

Do you have a suggestion for a paper? Then let us know.

Click here

Watch our 2 minute promo video!

Visit our other Elf blogs

  • Commissioning
  • Dentistry
  • Education
  • Learning Disabilities
  • Mental Health
  • Musculoskeletal
  • Social Care

Free trial

Close
Ready to get started? It's free!
Sign up now No thanks Tell me more about the benefits of membership

Free email newsletter

FOLLOW the Social Care Elf

  • Find us on Facebook
  • Follow us on Twitter
  • Follow us on Google+
  • Read our RSS feed
  • Find us on LinkedIn
© 2023 National Elf Service is brought to you by Minervation Ltd
Email: info@nationalelfservice.net
  • About
  • Evaluation
  • Site Map
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Cookies
  • Log In