The support of individuals with experience of psychosis is complex and relies on a combination of psychopharmacology (antipsychotic drugs), psychological therapies and social interventions. Antipsychotics will often be the first line treatment offered, with the intention of reducing psychotic symptom burden.
Following the resolution of immediate symptoms the role of antipsychotics becomes less clear; should they be discontinued, or maintained in order to reduce the risk of future relapse? Influential clinical guidelines recommend that antipsychotic treatment be continued for at least one year following initiation before consideration is given to their discontinuation (NICE, 2009 and Lehman, 2004). Experience shows however that concordance with antipsychotic treatment is not always maintained (Perkins et al, 2008), even within the initial year’s recommended treatment period.
The highest level evidence relating to long term maintenance treatment is provided by a recent meta-analysis comparing antipsychotic with placebo for relapse prevention (Leucht et al 2012). The study demonstrated lower rates of relapse with antipsychotic treatment and lower rates of hospital admission. No conclusions could be drawn in relation to factors such as social involvement, for example through employment, or overall death rates, owing to the rarity of events. The included studies were also limited in the length of follow up; with only three continuing to two years and one reaching three years of follow up. The authors recommended that future studies adopt measures relating to social involvement, or quality of life, as outcome measures for assessment.
A recent study published in JAMA Psychiatry seeks to address these concerns through comparing initial long term antipsychotic treatment with a targeted discontinuation strategy after a period of 7 years (Wunderink et al 2013).
The authors present data at 7 year follow up after an initial two year RCT comparing maintenance antipsychotic treatment with a directed discontinuation strategy (Wunderink et al 2007).
The original trial randomised participants with first episode psychosis, who achieved 6 month symptom remission with antipsychotic therapy, to either maintenance treatment or discontinuation strategy.
Discontinuation strategy involved dose reduction in negotiation with the patient until either the antipsychotic was discontinued or a balance between symptoms and antipsychotic side-effects were achieved.
Seven year follow up involved an interview with participants during which symptom severity and social functioning in the past 6 months were assessed. Data was also gathered relating to relapses during the follow up period, antipsychotic use during the past two years (interview and clinical record review).
Outcome measures included:
- Recovery: defined as a 6 month period of symptom and functional remission (all scores mild or absent, no significant domains of functional difficulty identified)
- Relapse: any increase in symptoms lasting at least one week
- Antipsychotic use and dosage
The original trial at 2 year follow up showed increased rates of relapse in the discontinuation strategy group compared to maintenance treatment, but no difference in functional assessment.
128 participants completed the original study and 103 were located and consented to participate at follow up (1 suicide death, 18 refused consent, 6 lost to follow up).
Recovery at follow up
- Rates of recovery were greater in the discontinuation group (40.4%) than in the maintenance group (9%)
- Symptom remission rates did not differ between groups (Dose reduction (DR) 69.2% Maintenance treatment (MT) 66.7%)
- Functional remission occurred more frequently in the discontinuation group (46.2% vs 19.6%)
Predictors of recovery
Baseline predictors of recovery included:
- Trial arm
- Initial psychosis severity (all sub-scales)
- Social functioning score
Symptomatic remission was predicted by baseline:
- Duration of untreated psychosis
- Social functioning score
- Negative symptoms of psychosis score
Functional remission was predicted by:
- Trial arm
- Living alone
- Social functioning score
- Psychosis symptom severity score
- The mean number of relapses over 7 years was 1.24 (SD 1.37) with no intergroup difference
- Initial rates of relapse in the discontinuation group were twice those in the maintenance treatment group
- No difference in relapse rates between groups was maintained after 3 years
- The mean prescribed antipsychotic dose was less in the discontinuation than maintenance group
- This dose difference was statistically significant throughout the two year period
The authors concluded:
Dose reduction/discontinuation of antipsychotics during the early stages of remitted FEP (first episode psychosis) shows superior long-term recovery rates compared with the rates achieved with MT. To our knowledge, this is the first study showing long-term gains of an early-course DR strategy in patients with remitted FEP. Additional studies are necessary before these results are incorporated into general practice.
This study presents us with an initial exploration of an under-researched area. It has rightly attracted a great deal of critical interest in relation to its findings and their implications for clinical practice.
The methodology of the study prevent causal inferences being drawn in relation to treatment strategies; although assessment of antipsychotic doses suggests that treatment differences persisted between trial arms. It could also be commented that the nature of the original recruitment strategy (where only half of those approached consented to participate) may have selected a group with less severe psychotic experiences. Setting aside these limitations, and accepting this trial as an initial exploration, it is difficult not to find the differences between the maintenance and directed reduction strategies compelling.
This is an important area of research and the incorporation of social function outcomes as a key methodology in this research is to be praised as this allows a more detailed discussion to be held around the role of antipsychotics. The authors are right to call for further research and while this study alone is likely insufficient to precipitate immediate change in clinical practice, it should at the least, promote a serious debate among professionals and a detailed look at the use of antipsychotics.
Wunderink, L., Nieboer, R. M., Wiersma, D., Sytema, S., & Nienhuis, F. J. (2013). Recovery in Remitted First-Episode Psychosis at 7 Years of Follow-up of an Early Dose Reduction/Discontinuation or Maintenance Treatment Strategy. JAMA Psychiatry, 70(9), 913. [PubMed abstract]
Schizophrenia: core interventions in the treatment and management of schizophrenia in adults in primary and secondary care (PDF). National Institute for Clinical Excellence, Clinical Guideline 82, Mar 2009.
Lehman, A. F., Lieberman, J. A., Dixon, L. B., McGlashan, T. H., Perkins, D., & Kreyenbuhl, J. (2004). Practice Guidelines for the Treatment of Patients With Schizophrenia (2nd ed.). American Psychiatric Association.
Perkins, D., Hongbin, G. U., & Weiden, P. J. (2008). Predictors of Treatment Discontinuation and Medication Non adherence in Patients recovering from a first episode of schizophrenia, schizophreniform disorder, or schizoaffective disorder: a randomized, double-blind, flexible-dose, multicenter study. The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 69(1), 106–113. [PubMed abstract]
Leucht, S., Tardy, M., Komossa, K., Heres, S., Kissling, W., Salanti, G., & Davis, J. M. (2012). Antipsychotic drugs versus placebo for relapse prevention in schizophrenia: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Lancet, 379(9831), 2063–2071. [PubMed abstract]
Wunderink, L., Nienhuis, F. J., & Sytema, S. (2007). Guided discontinuation versus maintenance treatment in remitted first-episode psychosis: relapse rates and functional outcome. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 68(5), 654–661. [PubMed abstract]
Moncrieff, J. Long-term antipsychotics – making sense of the evidence.
Long term maintenance treatment with antipsychotics: a cautionary note from recent research: The support of in… http://t.co/pseS5hYZws
Long term use of #antipsychotics Those who discontinue them do better. http://t.co/yaNqhQu2O5
Don’t miss this great debut blog from @shrinking81 on reducing antipsychotic use http://t.co/mggJ6wtOt2 Welcome to the woodland Andrew! :-)
New study suggests that reducing antipsychotics in a gradual & supported manner, brings better long-term outcomes http://t.co/mggJ6wtOt2
RT @shrinking81: My first blog on long term antipsychotic use published on @Mental_Elf http://t.co/ogHiR6tso1
@GGZFriesland We have blogged about your research today. Please let us know what you think http://t.co/mggJ6wtOt2 @shrinking81
Er is een blog geschreven door @Mental_Elf over het onderzoek van onze psychiater en A-opleider Lex Wunderink: http://t.co/TfTTkyb1di
More evidence for managed wthdrwl : Long term maintenance treatment with antipsychs: cautionary note from recent rsch http://t.co/0bpAg86Miv
@joannamoncrieff Tx for yr blog: http://t.co/Mpv8pdTVPB We’d love to hear your thoughts on our blog: http://t.co/mggJ6wtOt2 @shrinking81
@joannamoncrieff: “tentative confirmation that long-term antipsychotic use impairs people’s ability to function” http://t.co/mggJ6wtOt2
Recent follow-up of RCT raises concerns for confidence in long term antipsychotic treatment http://t.co/mggJ6wtOt2
Lex Wunderink nos hablará en las #JornadasANPIR de uno de los estudios más influyentes en el campo de la psicosis: http://t.co/7lv0PfRDqx
Discontinuation may outperform maintenance treatment in long term antipsychotic prescribing http://t.co/mggJ6wtOt2
@Mental_Elf …in self-selecting people who had remitted in their first episode. Only 45% had schizophrenia. http://t.co/aM2NlJYuOI
@Mental_Elf This is being hailed as generalisable to *all* patients on antipsychotics but it’s almost certainly not. We simply don’t know…
@dchristmas @Mental_Elf Not immediately generalisable to all on antipsychotics – but surely indicates urgent need for debate more research?
@Mental_Elf I’ll say!
@JAMAPsych study raises questions for guidance on long term #antipsychotic treatment in #schizophrenia http://t.co/mggJ6wtOt2
@JAMA Study raises questions for guidance on long term #antipsychotic treatment in #schizophrenia http://t.co/nAEL0rZs8U”
RT @Mental_Elf: Our blog today takes a fresh look at treatment strategies for long term antipsychotic prescribing http://t.co/mggJ6wtOt2
RT @shrinking81: My blog @Mental_Elf sparked a Twitter debate on outcome measures – made for a fun Friday afternoon. http://t.co/4R77ZS2eE3
This might be of interest to people on antipyschotic drugs – http://t.co/AbEUj0CYrT
In case you missed it: Long term maintenance treatment with #antipsychotics: a cautionary note from recent research http://t.co/mggJ6wtOt2
@Mental_Elf misses out important point that most (I think 2/3) on discontinuation group ended up back on antipsychotics albeit usu Lo dose
@Mental_Elf also discontinuation after 12 months of first episode is what we do in our EIT And I suspect many EITS do this also
@Mental_Elf there was debate on this paper at conf recently between wunderink & shon lewis. Agreed some limitations in trial design
@Mental_Elf Won’t be 1-size-fits-all re antipsychotics- must both end reckless overuse & identify who needs maintenance
@AllenFrancesMD @Mental_Elf trying to get MH to reduce someone’s depo seems to be impossible meanwhile uncertain Dx and SE ++
@AllenFrancesMD @Mental_Elf need to think harder about less than daily dosing? http://t.co/lN3eoT2yXa
Mental Elf: Long term maintenance treatment with antipsychotics: a cautionary note from recent research http://t.co/m8f8BovtRp
RT @Mental_Elf New study suggests reducing antipsychotics in a gradual & supported manner, brings better outcomes http://t.co/STw2PeQ3Ps
Most popular blog last week: Long term maintenance treatment with #antipsychotics http://t.co/mggJ6wtOt2 Great debut from @shrinking81
RT @Mental_Elf: Most popular blog last wk: Long term maintenance Tx w/ #antipsychotics http://t.co/YBGw5SWjOu Great debut from @shrinking81
Long term maintenance treatment with #antipsychotics : A cautionary note from recent research http://t.co/1s92LrnJUJ
Long term maintenance treatment with antipsychotics: a cautionary note http://t.co/mggJ6wtOt2 #schizophreniaawarenessweek #plustwenty