In February 2016, Trisha Greenhalgh and 75 senior academic colleagues from 11 countries wrote a letter calling on the British Medical Journal to rethink their decision to view qualitative research as “low priority,” “unlikely to be highly cited,” “lacking practical value,” or “not of interest to our readers”.
Researchers from McGill Qualitative Health Research Group helpfully shared their rejection letter on Twitter on 30 Sep 2015. Here’s their tweet and an excerpt from the BMJ response to their paper:
BMJ review: Sorry but qualitative studies are an extremely low priority Our research shows they are not widely accessed, downloaded or cited
— MQHRG (@mqhrg) September 30, 2015
Thank you for sending us your paper. We read it with interest but I am sorry to say that qualitative studies are an extremely low priority for The BMJ. Our research shows that they are not as widely accessed, downloaded, or cited as other research.
We receive over 8,000 submissions a year and accept less than 4%. We do therefore have to make hard decisions on just how interesting an article will be to our general clinical readers, how much it adds, and how much practical value it will be.
Here in the woodland we’ve been mulling over this matter for a few weeks. We have been rereading many of the qualitative research blogs that we’ve published, especially on the Mental Elf and the Social Care Elf and we have found ourselves asking: “What has qualitative research ever done for us?”
On Wednesday 13th April (1500-1600 BST) we will be hosting an expert webinar to bring together people from the world of mental health qualitative research, to share their experiences, celebrate the achievements of specific studies/programmes, and discuss the challenges currently facing the field.
We would like you to be involved in this discussion, which starts today and will run (we hope) for a few weeks. Listed below are the questions we will be asking our expert panel on April 13th.
Questions for our #ElfCampfire discussion
- Why is qualitative research considered to be less important than quantitative research?
- What is the most important “landmark” qualitative research study in mental health?
- How can we weed out unreliable or irrelevant qualitative research?
- What is mixed-methods research and how can it help us improve mental health care?
Please share your thoughts and experiences with us by adding a comment at the end of this blog or by tweeting to @Mental_Elf. Feel free to ask questions that you would like us to put to the panel.
Our expert panel
We are delighted to have convened a group of service users, researchers and practitioners with a wealth of experience about mental health qualitative research:
- Sarah Carr, Associate Professor of Mental Health Research, Middlesex University
- Michael Coffey, Associate Professor, Public Health, Policy and Social Sciences, Swansea University
- Steve Gillard, Reader in Social and Community Mental Health, St George’s University
- Trish Groves, Head of Research, BMJ
- Ben Hannigan, Reader in Mental Health Nursing, Cardiff University
- Sarah Knowles, Research Fellow, University of Manchester
- Tara Lamont, Scientific Advisor, Health Services and Delivery Research (HS&DR) Programme
- Eimear Muir-Cochrane, Professor of Nursing, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Flinders University
- Steven Pryjmachuk, Professor of Mental Health Nursing Education, University of Manchester
- Alan Simpson, Professor, School of Health Sciences, City University
- André Tomlin (Chair)
- Douglas Badenoch (National Elf Service)
The expert video webinar will be live broadcast and free to view at 3pm UK time on Wednesday 13th April. Simply join us around the campfire to watch the broadcast, or tweet your comments and questions to #ElfCampfire.
Links
What has qualitative research ever done for us? Elf Campfire, 13 Apr 2016.
An open letter to The BMJ editors on qualitative research.
Photo credits
krysiacanvin
10 years agoCNWLlibraries
10 years agotrished
10 years agoRuthWadman
10 years agoCenterQP
10 years agoMal_RahmanAmin
10 years agorsj_talbot
10 years agoJoeJudgePsy
10 years agoJoeJudgePsy
10 years agoSchrebersSister
10 years agobeffdizzle
10 years agoJo_KeeleIPCHS
10 years agoSameiHuda
10 years agoPOPPED_Project
10 years agoCasdok
10 years agoCatalyseC
10 years agoKat1eD
10 years agoOTBeth131
10 years agostevepclayton
10 years agoMental_Elf
10 years agosteph_coen
10 years agoMental_Elf
10 years agoMental_Elf
10 years agostevepclayton
10 years agoDrPPRam
10 years agod_galasinski
10 years agoMental_Elf
10 years agoJolyon_Poole
10 years agoCounterFett
10 years agoCounterFett
10 years agoJayDuckworth
10 years agoJComorbidity
10 years agoMental_Elf
10 years agoLivveyKirtley
10 years agoEvInsights
10 years agofluxopensamento
10 years agobaggybinny
10 years agocityalan
10 years agocharliemuss
10 years agoMOostwaard
10 years agoLPFTResearch
10 years agoDoSho
10 years agoLucie Kodiak
10 years agosamistigger
10 years agoHet_Roberts
10 years agoGaryWinship
10 years agoNiclaS44
10 years agosarahdrabble
10 years agoDenise O' Shea
10 years agoAilish O Brien
10 years agocityalan
10 years agoAmmTowers
10 years agorhapsodyrose
10 years agoha97lw
10 years agoNannon_Phillips
10 years agoCHSS_Kent
10 years agoMental_Elf
10 years agojacki_liddle
10 years agosparki23
10 years agoFizzAnnand
10 years agomorrisKOT
10 years agoNickyHaire
10 years agoMentalIllPolicy
10 years agoKatiePaddockPhD
10 years agoRoseEssex
10 years agoAlyson Price
10 years agoKristina Randle
10 years agoCynthia Virtue
10 years agoLail Lanni
10 years agofabngroovy
10 years agofabngroovy
10 years agojanitor1999
10 years agodjrobotham
10 years agoKTatWaypoint
10 years agoLucyACTerry
10 years agoLucyACTerry
10 years agodnunan79
10 years agoMental_Elf
10 years agoMental_Elf
10 years agoMaryBirken
10 years agoCharlotteKitch6
10 years agoCNWLlibraries
10 years agoJo_KeeleIPCHS
10 years agoNurseEdUK
10 years agoLizAllibone
10 years agohelenjosman
10 years agoMental_Elf
10 years agojanitor1999
10 years agojanitor1999
10 years agoCenterQP
10 years agodjrobotham
10 years agoKKavalidou
10 years agoLucyACTerry
10 years agodnunan79
10 years agodnunan79
10 years agoLucyACTerry
10 years agoJessica Beaty
10 years agopsychwatch2
10 years agoLizHughesDD
10 years agoCatalyseC
10 years agohelenjosman
10 years agoOxINAHR
10 years agotraymca
10 years agoIntl_Nurses
10 years agoMental_Elf
10 years agoCNWLlibraries
10 years ago_Lucibee
10 years agoSameiHuda
10 years agoThriveAppsUK
10 years agoAli Smith
10 years agoM Anne Martin
10 years agoTori Cooper
10 years agoCatD_OT
10 years agoUCLDementiaMSc
10 years agoEvidSynthTeam
10 years agoLizMonaghan5
10 years agoCatalyseC
10 years agoian_hamilton_
10 years agoMental_Elf
10 years agoTraceyJPallett
10 years agoGenFrorath
10 years agoafwesty
10 years agoHHLibService
10 years agojellico1915
10 years agoMHNProfSteven
10 years agoNorthwayRuth
10 years agoNorthwayRuth
10 years agoPPI_poppet
10 years agoSallyHardys
10 years agoKirsten Corden
10 years agoBibi Senthi
10 years agoThe Mental Elf
10 years agoJas Kaur
10 years agomalcolmclayton
10 years agomilton_damian
10 years agoJohnBaker_Leeds
10 years agoHelenMcAvoy2
10 years agocuriousnrse
10 years agocuriousnrse
10 years agoHelenMcAvoy2
10 years agoIzzy192451
10 years agoglittahcat
10 years agoNatashaSmasha
10 years agoMental_Elf
10 years agoBibi Senthi
10 years agoKarl_Tooher
10 years agoAliciaRidout
10 years agoRonaMossMorris
10 years agoCG_Sheikh
10 years agoiVivekMisra
10 years agoBethan Davies
10 years agoLaurelMildred
10 years agoCenterQP
10 years agostatsguyuk
10 years agoIntl_Nurses
10 years agoiahcp
10 years ago