People with substance misuse problems often present to services with complex physical and mental health needs. Studies in the UK have indicated that common mental health problems are the norm in people in treatment for substance misuse. Weaver et al (2003) found 70% of people in treatment for substance misuse in London also had a mental health problem; most commonly depression, anxiety and personality disorders. A more recent study in Leeds has found similar rates of comorbidity (Delgadillo et al, 2013).
In addition to mental health problems people with drug misuse problems have a greater risk of physical health problems associated directly from drug use (such as blood borne viruses from injecting) as well as health risks associated with a drug using lifestyle. A major cause of premature death amongst drug users is accidental over-dose (Ghodse et al 2012) and this can be as a result of lowered tolerance (after a detox for example or prison stay), misjudging effects of a combination of drugs, and/or an increase in strength of the street drugs. So it is likely that drug users will also require treatment from mental health and general health services.
Previous research (Merrell et al, 2010) has established that there is a high risk of death in the immediate two week period of release from prison, and recommendations are that people with a history of drug use should be offered immediate support from local services on release. However, it is not been examined if there is a similar risk after release from hospital.
The aim of the study was to investigate mortality rates amongst drug users in relation to time after discharge from hospital, specifically focusing on drug related deaths (DRD) and non-drug related death (suicide).
This was a cohort study using data linked to 69 457 people who were registered for drug treatment from April 1996 – March 2006.
- Population: substance misusers identified within the Scottish Drug Misuse Database.
- Time at risk was calculated as date of first attendance to drug services to death, or end of study, and categorised according to time since most recent hospitalisation.
- Main outcome was DRD. This was defined as all deaths recorded with an ICD-10 code indicating mental or behavioural disorder due to psychoactive substance misuse, accidental poisoning, intentional self-poisoning, assault by drugs medicaments and biological substances, and poisoning with undetermined intent. Non-DRD were defined as any suicide excluding those above.
There were four categories of “time to death”: within 28 days, 29-90 days, 91 days to 1 year, and >1 year and these were compared with those “never admitted” to hospital.
- Overall in the 10 year period, out of 69 457 individuals, there were 2590 deaths recorded (3.72%). Of these over half were recorded as Drug-Related Deaths, and 10% non-DRD (i.e. suicide).
- In the analysis of the links between time after discharge and death, the time periods closest to discharge from hospital were associated with increased risk of DRD.
- Death during hospitalisation associated with greater risk of DRD and non-DRD.
- The greatest risk of death occurred within 28 days (Hazard Ratio [HR] 9.6; 95% CI 8-12) and reduced as time period grew longer.
- The risk of death also increased if there were more hospitalisations.
People with substance misuse problems have a greater risk of death in the immediate month after discharge from hospital. Characteristics of being an alcohol user, an injecting drug user, and having a hepatitis C diagnosis increases this risk. These findings mirror the findings of research examining deaths after prison and discharge from drug treatments. It is important to note that these deaths are avoidable, and all services need to consider how they can play a role in prevention strategies for this marginalised group.
The recommendation of the paper is for hospitals to have a greater role in reducing these risks. Three suggestions are made:
- Drug liaison nurses at hospital who can raise awareness of risks to service users.
- Hospitals alerting GPs as part of discharge process.
- Hospitals to have naloxone (heroin antidote) for users to take away as it is available for prisoners on release from prison.
However, an important point to note is that the hospitalisations were relatively brief with a quarter not involving an over-night stay. This suggests that some of the deaths are unlikely to be linked to lowered tolerance (as in after a period of weeks or months in prison).
This paper has been able to analyse data from large data-sets which makes the findings both robust and generalisable (to drug users who attend drug treatment).
Routine data sets are problematic as they may not be accurate (i.e events wrongly coded when inputted in the system) and also may under-report actual events by omission of data. The authors admit that despite methods used for accurate linkage there is a small chance of some errors within the dataset. Analysis of routine data-sets such as this can identify a pattern, but can’t answer deeper questions about specific relationships and why this is occurring. This analysis only included drug users who had attended for drug treatment and therefore not all drug users in Scotland. In addition, the authors did not differentiate between types of hospital admissions and this could have been useful in identifying which conditions are associated with greater risk. For example it may be that this increased risk is being mediated by accidental overdoses which is a marker for a person who is engaging in significant health risks, and is at increased risk of dying. It would have been useful to compare risks associated with discharge from psychiatric hospital compared with general medical hospitals. Again, we are not sure from this analysis whether the risk of death is associated with underlying mental health issues.
It is clear that there is a need for further research to fully understand the link between hospital discharge and death in order to develop and test preventative strategies where they would have most impact. However, in the meantime, all health services should recognise the heightened risks associated with substance misuse and provide the necessary care and discharge plans to help minimise this risk. This group of people have complex health and social needs and are often marginalised and stigmatised. The rate of premature mortality in this group is high and reflects a significant health inequality that needs to be addressed.
If you need help
If you need help and support now and you live in the UK or the Republic of Ireland, please call the Samaritans on 116 123.
If you live elsewhere, we recommend finding a local Crisis Centre on the IASP website.
We also highly recommend that you visit the Connecting with People: Staying Safe resource.
Merrall, E. L. C., Bird, S. M. and Hutchinson, S. J. (2013), A record-linkage study of drug-related death and suicide after hospital discharge among drug-treatment clients in Scotland, 1996–2006. Addiction, 108: 377–384. doi: 10.1111/j.1360-0443.2012.04066.x [PubMed abstract]
Delgadillo, J., Godfrey, C., Gilbody, S., and Payne, S (2013) Depression, anxiety and comorbid substance use: association patterns in outpatient addictions treatment. Mental Health and Substance Use 6(1), 59-75
Ghodse, H., Corkery, J., Claridge, H., Goodair, C., and Schifano, F. Drug-related deaths in the UK. 13th Annual Report. St Georges Medical School http://www.sgul.ac.uk/media/np-sad2012/np-sad-13th-annual-report-2012finalversionfeb28thmastercopy.pdf
Merrell, E.L.C, Kariminia, A., Binswanger, I., Hobbs, M.S., Farrell, M., Marsden, J., Hutchinson, S.J. and Bird, S.M Meta-analysis of drug-related deaths soon after release from prison Addiction 105(9): 1545–1554
Weaver, T., Madden, P., Charles, V., Stimson, G., Renton, A., Tyrer, P., Barnes, T., Bench, C., Middleton, H., Wright, N., Paterson, S., Shanahan, W., Seivewright, N., Ford, C., (2003) Comorbidity of substance misuse and mental illness in community mental health and substance misuse services. British Journal of Psychiatry, 183, 304-13
Mortality rates amongst drug users in relation to time after hospital discharge: People with substance misuse … http://t.co/Ud4d1Y9oC8
“@Mental_Elf: Mortality rates amongst drug users in relation to time after hospital discharge http://t.co/fqin4VzhyG”> blog by @LizHughesDD
RT @Mental_Elf: We’ve another great blogger on @Mental_Elf It’s mental health nurse researcher @LizHughesDD Here’s her debut: http://t.co/z…
MT @Mental_Elf: New study recommends drug liaison nurses in hospital to reduce numbers of drug related deaths http://t.co/rgJtvFNIrP”
RT @Mental_Elf: New study recommends discharge alerts to GPs to reduce numbers of drug related deaths after discharge http://t.co/z9HegcXk0H
Australia -And Narcan
Study recommends drug liaison nurses to reduce numbers of drug related deaths after discharge http://t.co/mRMzZwSrnu”
YES FOR AUSTRALIA
New study recommends discharge alerts to GPs reduce numbers of drug related deaths after discharge http://t.co/mRMzZwSrnu”
New study recommends hospitals have naloxone to reduce numbers of drug related deaths after discharge http://t.co/z9HegcXk0H
RT @Mental_Elf: New study recommends drug liaison nurses in hospital to reduce numbers of drug related deaths after discharge http://t.co/z…
Mortality rates amongst #drug users in relation to time after hospital discharge http://t.co/cZplZgMe0B via @sharethis #mentalhealth
Health services must recognise risks associated w/ drug abuse & provide necessary care to help minimise risk http://t.co/z9HegcXk0H
In case you missed it: Mortality rates amongst drug users in relation to time after hospital discharge http://t.co/jkB0vqlpwy
@Mental_Elf I feel all grown up, for knowing one of the authors cited in this article. One of yrs, @RobWebster_LCH Top bloke, Mr Delgadillo
@_jonb @mental_elf yes – a real asset @LCHNHSTrust & part of burgeoning research team. Interesting paper @NHSLeedsSE http://t.co/UNJkW40hKY
Mortality rates amongst drug users in relation to time after hospital discharge http://t.co/fogA1w9ZMl via @sharethis
Mental Elf: Mortality rates amongst drug users in relation to time after hospital discharge http://t.co/3TKoohOcKU
RT @StephenCMalloy: People with drug problems have greater risk of death in the immediate month after discharge from hospital. #naloxone ht…
RT @posseproject: Mortality rates amongst drug users in relation to time after hospital discharge – The Mental Elf http://t.co/I7S78exbp5
[…] Les omtalen i The Mental Elf her […]