Psychiatric drugs are as effective as other drugs, says new review of meta-analyses


There’s an interesting review in the British Journal of Psychiatry this week, which compares the effectiveness of psychiatric drugs with those used to treat physical health problems. The headline from the review is that ‘psychiatric drugs are as effective as other drugs’.

Professor Stefan Leucht who led the review team claims that:

There is a deep mistrust of psychiatry, fostered by reports suggesting that the efficacy of psychiatric drugs is very small. Psychiatrists, patients, carers and the media are often unsettled by these findings, and some may think that psychiatric medication is not worth the bother.

His team looked at 33 meta-analyses of 16 different drugs to treat psychiatric disorders (including schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, major depressive disorder, obsessive compulsive disorder, Alzheimer’s disorder and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder), and 94 meta-analyses of 48 drugs to treat medical diseases (including cardiovascular disease, hypertension, rheumatoid arthritis, chronic asthma, type 2 diabetes and hepatitis C).

They compared the effect sizes of the different drugs. An effect size of 0.2 is considered significant but low, and an effect size of 0.8 or above is considered high.

Some general medicine drugs had very high effect sizes, for example an effect size of 1.39 for proton pump inhibitors to treat reflux oesophagitis (commonly known as acid reflux), and an effect size of 2.27 of interferon to treat hepatitis C. But many commonly used general medicine drugs, such as statins and aspirin to prevent cardiovascular disease and stroke, had small effect sizes (0.12 for aspirin for secondary prevention of cardiovascular events and 0.15 for statins for cardiovascular events).

Overall, the effect sizes for the psychiatric drugs were found to be in the same range as the general medicine drugs. For example, antidepressants used as ‘maintenance treatment’ to prevent patients having a relapse of major depressive disorder had an effect size of 0.64, and antipsychotics used to prevent relapse in schizophrenia had an effect size of 0.92.

Taking all diseases, the mean effect sizes were only of medium size for both psychiatric and general medicine drugs.

The review concludes:

There are reasons why people should be critical about psychiatric drug treatment, such as a lack of diagnostic tests, commercial conflict of interest, unclear mechanism of drug action and side-effects. But our study shows that the psychiatric drugs were not generally inferior to those used in other medical specialties, and the effectiveness of psychiatric drugs is supported by randomised controlled trials.

Any comparison of different outcomes in different diseases can only serve the purpose of a qualitative perspective. The increment of improvement by drug over placebo must be viewed in the context of the disease’s seriousness, suffering induced, natural course, duration, outcomes, adverse events and societal values.

Leucht S, Hierl S, Kissling W, Dold M and Davis JM. Putting the efficacy of psychiatric and general medicine medication into perspective: review of meta-analyses. British Journal of Psychiatry 2012; 200: 97-106. [Abstract]

Share on Facebook Tweet this on Twitter Share on LinkedIn Share on Google+
Mark as read
Create a personal elf note about this blog
Profile photo of Andre Tomlin

Andre Tomlin

André Tomlin is an Information Scientist with 20 years experience working in evidence-based healthcare. He's worked in the NHS, for Oxford University and since 2002 as Managing Director of Minervation Ltd, a consultancy company who do clever digital stuff for charities, universities and the public sector. Most recently André has been the driving force behind the Mental Elf and the National Elf Service; an innovative digital platform that helps professionals keep up to date with simple, clear and engaging summaries of evidence-based research. André is a Trustee at the Centre for Mental Health and an Honorary Research Fellow at University College London Division of Psychiatry. He lives in Bristol, surrounded by dogs, elflings and lots of woodland!

More posts - Website

Follow me here –